As I-9 Program Administrators, you know the challenges presented by the human element. Electronic Form I-9 systems with real-time error-checking go a long way toward eliminating the issues created by the human element. But, even with error-checking software in place, there are still certain pitfalls that can occur.

  • Your I-9 Processor ignores the system alerts and prompts resulting in an erroneously completed Form I-9.
  • Your I-9 Processor does not know what to do when the new hire fails to present documents within 3 days of hire.
  • Your I-9 Processor does not know what to do with an incomplete Form I-9 if the new hire quits before the I-9 is completed.
  • Your I-9 Processor does not know what to do with an incomplete Form I-9 if the new hire never begins work.

Due to unique factors in your organization, many of these pitfalls require management and legal input to determine the best action to take. These determinations should be described in an I-9 policy manual and taught to I-9 processors during training sessions. In addition, a Program Administrator should be responsible for oversight and management of the organizations I-9 processing and policy enforcement.

Once again, electronic Form I-9 systems add efficiency to the oversight of Form I-9 processing. The ability to pull reports and search for specific events saves significant time. However, if your Program Administrator is not utilizing the reports regularly and effectively, your organization may find compliance issues continue to be overlooked.

Administrators should perform the following functions on a systematic basis to insure I-9 Policy and Program effectiveness.

  • Review all Form I-9s containing errors
  • Delete I-9s for new hires who never began work
  • Terminate I-9s for new hires who failed to provide documents to complete I-9
  • Resolve any curable errors, i.e., typos, conflicts of status, etc, for active employees
  • Compare Payroll records to Form I-9 records
  • Update Termination dates
  • Purge Retention Expired Form I-9s

If you require instruction or assistance on how to perform these tasks in the Lookout system, please contact Customer Support at 713-668-6200 x2. We look forward to the opportunity to assist you in managing the human element in your I-9 processing.

Lookout Services

Recent Posts

Hoja de Informacion para el Empleado Con Preguntas de el Formulario I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification (Español)

Employee guide on completing Form I-9, understanding document requirements, and knowing your rights. Includes answers…

2 weeks ago

Exciting News: i9 Intelligence Joins Forces with i9 Technologies

We’re excited to share a major milestone in our journey: as of December 31, 2024,…

2 weeks ago

Understanding the New Illinois E-Verify Law: Effective January 1, 2025

Starting January 1, 2025, Illinois employers utilizing the federal E-Verify system will face new obligations…

4 weeks ago

How to Select an I-9 System That Keeps Your Business Audit-Ready

When selecting an electronic I-9 form system, compliance is the top priority, as errors or…

1 month ago

Preparing for the Changing Landscape of Compliance Audits in 2025

As the U.S. government transitions into a new administration in 2025, businesses across the nation…

2 months ago

Understanding Document Receipts and How to Complete I-9 Forms

Note: The M-274 Handbook for Employers provides guidance on the acceptable receipts section for completing…

2 months ago